Objectives for this Activity: (as presented to students before activity or in syllabus)

A specific learning objective for this Module is to develop a functional understanding of the nature and importance of online learning in the context of contemporary educational offerings.

Prerequisites for this Activity: (not necessarily presented to students)

Student should have a desire to teach online and meet student needs.

Materials and Resources:

What needs to be prepared in advance by the teacher? - A listing of articles to help those that can't find one appropriate. Prepared summary statements as appropriate

What does the student need to bring to the lesson? - Complete prior readings.

Guiding Questions for this Activity: (not presented directly to students but a question that should be addressed in the readings)

What are the skills and responsibilities students need to succeed in the virtual classroom?

Activity as Presented to Students: (usually in conjunction with the asynchronous discussion forum)

evaluation.gifAssignment: Article Critique 

Purpose:

Students will be asked to submit critiques of an online article or Web resource relevant to the course content. This activity has three functions:

  • It allows students to choose what to focus on and take control of their own learning experience.
  • It brings outside resources into the course.
  • It provides participants with an extensive list of summaries of related resources which they can choose to read or archive for later use.

Postings:

Post your assignment in this forum no later than the date it appears in the course calendar. The Article/Resources Rubric will be used to evaluate the assignment.

Instructions:

Summarize and critique an online article or resource about the role of the student in online education or the nature and importance of online learning in the context of contemporary educational offerings . This should be an article other than one assigned for this course.  Think of this assignment as a way to build a collective online professional library.

  • Submit your critique here.
  • Put the article title and your name in the subject area of your posting
  • Include the complete URL (Web address) at the top of your posting (cutting and pasting it from your browser's address bar will avoid mistakes in doing this) so your classmates can link to the site. Make sure you include the http:// , so Moodle will automatically make a hyperlink.


This same activity modified to use a wiki instead of a discussion forum

evaluation.gifAssignment: Wiki

Purpose: Participants are asked to submit an annotated reference of an online article or resource relevant to the course content. This activity has three functions:

  • It allows students to choose what to focus on and take control of their own learning experience.

  • It brings outside resources into the course.

  • It provides participants with an extensive list of summaries of related resources which they can choose to read or archive for later use.

Postings: Post your assignment in the Wiki of Resources (toward the top of the home page) no later than the date it appears in the course calendar. The Wiki Rubric will be used to evaluate the assignment.Instructions:Annotate an online article or resource about the online student. This should be an article other than one assigned for this course or a web-based resource (e.g. link to an artchived webcast). Think of this assignment as a way to build a collective online professional library.

  • Submit your annotate reference in the Wiki of Resources [Note that as used, this would be a link to the resource].
  • Include the title of the reference and the complete URL (Web address) at the beginning of your posting (cutting and pasting it from your browser's address bar will avoid mistakes in doing this) so your classmates can link to the site. Make sure you include the http:// , so Moodle will automatically make a hyperlink.
  • Add 2-4 sentences that describe what the article or resource is about.
  • Add your name at the end of the posting.

Teaching Strategies:

What are some tips to help the lesson run smoothly? Patience is a key. Provide the students time to guide the discussion on the article assigned to them. Allow the students time to answer questions concerning their given article. Rather than provide direct answers, guide students to the answers of their questions. Try not to let misunderstandings linger, but at the same time allow for students to self correct or correct others.

Accommodations:

What accommodations may be needed for students with disabilities or other special needs? This lesson requires few if any accommodations. Most text to speech and speech to text programs can function within most asynchronous discussion tools. The bandwidth requirements are also low.

Ideas for Activity Evaluation and Teacher Reflection:

How did the students like the lesson? End of semester evaluations should ask about the usefulness and learning accomplished through such activities.

How was student learning verified? An assessment should be performed on the quality of both the initial response by students, and any counter responses. Furthermore, retention of the knowledge should be tested by students ability to build on this knowledge with later units.

Sample Rubric:

Evaluation Criteria

Proficient

Adequate

Not There at All

Ideas

Found an item related to the module's content area and introduced new ideas.
(2 pts)

Found an item marginally related to the module's content area. Quality does not add to the discussion or collective knowledge of the group.

(1 pt)

Did not complete the assignment
(0 pts)

Annotation

Sufficient annotation and brief summary
(2 pts)

Insufficient information to determine topic/scope of resource and/or URL
(1 pt)

Did not complete the assignment
(0 pts)

Timeliness

Posted on or before deadline
(1 pt)


Posted late or not at all
(0 pts)

 

Back to Top

arrow buttonReturn to Article Critique Activity
arrow buttonReturn to OTAI Main Page

 

University of Illinois
University of Illinois University of Illinois at Chicago University of Illinois at Springfield University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign